It depends on the failure mode. Cold-rolled flighting is stronger in surface hardness and fatigue resistance because of work hardening and a continuous weld-free helix. Pressed sectional flighting is stronger in section thickness and abrasive wear because it retains full plate thickness and accepts wear-resistant grades.
A flight can fail by surface wear, section yielding, fatigue cracking or weld failure. Each mode favors a different construction. Comparing “strength” without naming the mode produces misleading conclusions.
Cold rolling work-hardens the material and produces a smooth, harder surface. The continuous helix has no body weld, removing a common fatigue initiation site. In moderate abrasion and standard conveyor sizes, this construction performs well. A Continuous Screw Flight Cold Rolling Machine produces this type of flight.
The trade-off is edge thinning. The hardened surface is thinner at the rim, which is the primary wear zone. Surface hardness is higher, but the remaining section is smaller.
Pressed sectional flighting keeps uniform plate thickness and can be made from Hardox, AR plate or manganese steel. Wear resistance becomes a through-thickness property. For thick plate, large diameter and highly abrasive materials, this is the stronger construction. A Spiral Blade Forming Machine configured for sectional production forms the individual segments.
The trade-off is welding. Sectional flights require body welds or shaft welds, and weld quality determines whether the joint matches the parent plate. This is controllable through procedure and inspection.
Surface hardness: cold-rolled advantage.
Section thickness: pressed sectional advantage.
Weld-free fatigue resistance: cold-rolled advantage.
Abrasive wear life at large diameter: pressed sectional advantage.
Material grade flexibility: pressed sectional advantage.
For applications where geometry varies beyond fixed-roll capability, a Winding Spiral Blade Forming Machine offers a continuous alternative with different tooling economics.
State the governing failure mode, the material, the thickness and the diameter before asking which is stronger. A supplier who answers without these details is guessing.
Contact: Lucy Chai | Lucy.chai@huataogroup.com | www.refinerdisc.com | WhatsApp: +86 15373883537
#ScrewFlight #SpiralBlade #MetalForming #auger #screwconveyor #feedmixer #ColdRolling #SectionalFlight
can not be empty
can not be empty